The formula
Spirit + a little sugar + a couple dashes of bitters + a big piece of ice, stirred and expressed with citrus peel.
The Old Fashioned isn’t really a recipe so much as the original way to drink a spirit “the old-fashioned way” — something strong, lightly sweetened, seasoned with bitters, and chilled over a big piece of ice. That template travels: rum and demerara, agave spirits and agave nectar, brandy in Wisconsin supper clubs, maple in autumn. Each keeps the same low, spirit-forward balance; only the base and the sweetener move.
Start with the original, then work outward.
21+ Louisville, Kentucky (American whiskey country) · American
The cocktail that defined the word: good bourbon or rye, a little sugar, a couple dashes of bitters, and a big piece of ice. The proper build, the right ratio, and why it's stood for 150 years.
21+ Caribbean rum, American cocktail template · Caribbean
The Old Fashioned template poured over rum: rich aged rum, a little demerara sugar, a couple dashes of bitters and a big piece of ice. Molasses and vanilla in place of oak — spirit-forward, stirred, and deeply satisfying.
21+ Oaxaca, Mexico (agave heartland), via New York · Mexican
The modern-classic agave Old Fashioned: reposado tequila and a little mezcal, agave nectar in place of sugar, and bitters over a big cube. Earthy, smoky and spirit-forward — a Death & Co. creation that became a canon drink.
21+ Wisconsin (Midwestern supper clubs) · American
Wisconsin's state drink: brandy muddled with sugar, bitters, orange and cherry, topped with lemon-lime soda for the classic 'sweet.' A supper-club institution — fruitier and fizzier than the whiskey original, and utterly its own thing.
21+ American Northeast (maple country) · American
The autumn Old Fashioned: bourbon sweetened with pure maple syrup instead of sugar, dressed with aromatic bitters over a big cube. Woodsy, warm and just as spirit-forward as the original — a seasonal favourite that earns its place year-round.
21+ American cocktail bars (modern) · American
The showpiece Old Fashioned: a classic bourbon build finished under a dome of wood smoke that clings to the glass. Same spirit-forward drink, wrapped in campfire aroma — the theatrical modern favourite, made at home with a smoker or a torched chip.
21+ London dry gin, American cocktail template · British
The Old Fashioned template poured over gin: a juniper-forward gin, a touch of sugar and orange bitters over a big cube. Crisp and aromatic where the whiskey version is warm — an elegant, spirit-forward showcase for a gin you love.
Back to the full Drinks collection or the Drinks guide.